Morning Briefing
Summaries of health policy coverage from major news organizations
Different Takes: Reopening The Economy Must Not Involve A Fight Over Leadership That Confuses Americans; Lessons On Planning How To Return To Work When There's No Cure
At long last our political leaders are considering how they can reopen the American economy they put into a destructive coma. Let鈥檚 hope this overdue process doesn鈥檛 devolve into another fight between governors and President Trump that will confuse Americans and slow the return to normal economic life. New York Governor Andrew Cuomo took the lead Monday by announcing a committee of six Northeast states aimed at reopening the economy without sacrificing the gains made so far, and at such a great cost, against the coronavirus. New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island and Delaware will each name a public-health official, an economic policy maven and the chief of staff for each Governor to the committee. (4/13)
Controversy over when President Trump will 鈥渞eopen the country鈥 is nothing more than another ploy to spice up his tiresome reality-show drama. Trump won鈥檛 determine when it鈥檚 safe again for us to mingle again at work and play. We will. Trump said Friday that when to restart what he called 鈥渢he greatest economy ever created鈥 will be 鈥渂y far the biggest decision of my life.鈥 He claimed Monday in a tweet that when to 鈥渙pen up the states .鈥.鈥. is the decision of the president, for many good reasons.鈥 He pretends there is a switch and that he alone can flick it, but of course no such thing exists. This crisis is not all about him. It鈥檚 all about us. (Eugene Robinson, 4/13)
Columnist Holman Jenkins offered an analogy in the Wall Street Journal over the weekend that captures the conundrum created by the U.S. response to COVID-19. 鈥淚magine a problem that can be solved by holding your head underwater,鈥 Jenkins wrote, 鈥渂ut stops being solved when you lift your head out.鈥 In other words, the stay-at-home measures adopted to protect against the outbreak are damaging in their own right, and not a cure for the disease. In fact, there is no known cure, just a number of drug therapies being tested and vaccines in development. That鈥檚 why it鈥檚 so disturbing to hear President Trump assert, as he did again Monday, that he has the power to 鈥渙pen up the states,鈥 presumably by lifting the restrictions on movement and commerce. (4/13)
Expectations are running high that reopening the United States will mean returning to offices, factories and schools, kick-starting the economy and rediscovering life before the novel coronavirus pandemic. At best these alluring goals are likely to be achieved haltingly, partially, more slowly than we would like 鈥 and how haltingly will depend heavily on how well the nation undertakes a mammoth set of public health tasks. The inescapable fact is that in the absence of a vaccine or drug therapy for the next year or more, a highly infectious virus will roam the country and the world, and only strenuous actions can prevent continuing flare-ups or new explosions such as Wuhan, Bergamo or New York City. (4/13)
Though a broad segment of political and media opinion continues to proclaim that the coronavirus pandemic demands a strengthening of international cooperation and multilateral institutions, the facts on the ground demonstrate that the tide of events is聽 moving in precisely the opposite direction. The emerging reality is that individual nation-states increasingly are in the driver鈥檚 seat and being strongly supported by their populations, while multilateral institutions from the United Nations to the European Union (EU) are falling victim to their internal contradictions and a consequent inability to act quickly or decisively in the face of the global crisis. (William Moloney, 4/13)
When I sat down with [Chris] Christie (virtually, of course) for the latest episode of "The Axe Files" podcast, I asked him why the President was so insistent on downplaying the burgeoning threat of Covid-19 for six critical weeks and why the Trump Administration was so slow in responding. "He always believes that by sheer force of will he can change circumstances," Christie told me. "And I think that he was like, 'OK, if I just go out there, talk this thing down, it'll come down.' I think that's what he felt at the beginning. (David Axelrod, 4/13)
Though the federal government has repeatedly assured Americans that it is doing all it can to stop the spread of the coronavirus, one controversial agency may well be enabling its spread rather than actively participating in slowing it down, while claiming the mantle of protecting 鈥渘ational security.鈥 But there is nothing more essential to the security of the American people than overcoming this immediate public health disaster 鈥 especially not institutionalized racism. (Julio Ricardo Varela, 4/13)
No one should have to choose between their right to vote and their health. There are steps we can take to ensure access to the ballot for Missouri voters in 2020, but the time for decisive action is now. Missouri lawmakers returned to session last week. They must appropriate funds to scale up increased mail-in voting and other measures. And Missouri鈥檚 chief elections official must offer clear direction on the path forward and ensure local election authorities have the resources they need to administer what will certainly be the most unusual and challenging elections in our lifetimes. (Denise Lieberman, 4/13)
The COVID-19 global pandemic poses a severe threat to health, to the economy and to our system of funding health care in the United States. Employers can play an important role in addressing the threat of this coronavirus, but we also need effective government action to save lives and to preserve the viability of businesses across the country.聽(Dr. Jeff Levin-Scherz, 4/13)
Gov. Gavin Newsom has made 鈥渕eet the moment鈥 a mantra during the coronavirus crisis. He has been impressive in pushing stay-at-home orders, acquiring protective equipment and ventilators, expanding the health care workforce, and keeping the state鈥檚 interest above egos and partisan rivalries in collaborating with the Trump White House. The next step for California would be to ensure that it is optimizing the services of the 13,000 physician assistants in the state. About 80% of the assistants work in hospitals or clinics, where the range of care they provide is often broad. (4/13)