Morning Briefing
Summaries of health policy coverage from major news organizations
FDA May Probe Its Own Approval Of Alzheimer's Drug
The acting head of the Food and Drug Administration on Friday called for a government investigation into highly unusual contacts between her agency鈥檚 drug reviewers and the maker of a controversial new Alzheimer鈥檚 drug. Dr. Janet Woodcock announced the extraordinary step via Twitter. It鈥檚 the latest fallout over last month鈥檚 approval of Aduhelm, an expensive and unproven therapy that the agency OK鈥檇 against the advice of its own outside experts. (Perrone, 7/9)
In a letter to the Department of Health and Human Services鈥 independent Office of the Inspector General, the F.D.A.鈥檚 acting commissioner, Dr. Janet Woodcock, acknowledged the scrutiny the agency has faced about the approval process for the drug, which is known as Aduhelm and has a $56,000 annual price tag. She pointed to interactions between representatives from the drug鈥檚 developer, Biogen, and the agency, saying some 鈥渕ay have occurred outside of the formal correspondence process.鈥 鈥淭o the extent these concerns could undermine the public鈥檚 confidence in F.D.A.鈥檚 decision, I believe it is critical that the events at issue be reviewed by an independent body,鈥 Dr. Woodcock wrote. She noted that the review should look at whether any of the communication between the agency鈥檚 staff and Biogen鈥檚 representatives violated F.D.A. rules. (Robbins, 7/9)
The drug鈥檚 approval has been highly controversial, partly because of its annual price pegged at $56,000, and partly because evidence of the drug鈥檚 effectiveness was inconclusive. During the time when the agency was considering the drug, called Aduhelm, FDA reviewers met with the company, Biogen Inc., that makes the drug. They collaborated with the company to prepare a joint review document presented to an FDA panel of outside advisers at a public meeting in 2020. The watchdog group Public Citizen called in December for an inspector general investigation 鈥渢o scrutinize the unprecedented close collaboration.鈥 (Burton, 7/9)
Neurologist Matthew S. Schrag was surprised when he heard the Food and Drug Administration had approved a controversial Alzheimer鈥檚 drug. There was scant evidence the treatment worked, in his view. Even more concerning to Schrag: the FDA鈥檚 apparent embrace of a long-debated theory about Alzheimer鈥檚 disease, which afflicts more than 6 million Americans. The amyloid hypothesis, which has dominated the field for decades, holds that toxic clumps in the brain, called amyloid beta, are the main driver of the disease and that removing them will slow cognitive decline. (McGinley, 7/10)
Biogen Inc.鈥檚 new $56,000-a-year Alzheimer鈥檚 drug could wind up costing thousands of dollars more per patient than the company has said because of quirks in the way the therapy and others like it are packaged and paid for. Medicare and other insurers could wind up paying $61,000 to $62,000 a patient on average depending on the dosages each needs, according to an analysis published online Friday by the journal Health Affairs. (Walker, 7/9)