Morning Briefing
Summaries of health policy coverage from major news organizations
Different Takes: The Reality Of Rationed Care In The ER; The Public Is Confused About Booster Shots
Dear 鈥淧ersonal Choicers,鈥 As long as unvaccinated people provide a significant breeding ground for COVID-19 virus variants, medical care for those seriously ill with coronavirus will be diminished. Rationing hospital patient admissions has become urgently necessary because of depleted staff and limitations of space and equipment. (Diana C. Schramm, 9/28)
In a virtually unprecedented move, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Director Rochelle Walensky announced at 1:00 a.m. last Friday that she was very broadly approving booster shots for people under 65 whose occupations may put them at heightened risk from the coronavirus. While the announcement aligned with a September 17 recommendation by experts at the FDA's Vaccines and Related Biological Products Advisory Committee (VRBPAC), it directly contradicted a key CDC advisory panel, which had advised against approving boosters for people under 65. The panel in turn contradicted President Joe Biden. On August 18, he declared to all Americans, "Get a booster shot.... It will make you safer, and for longer. And it will help us end the pandemic faster." (David Gortler, 9/29)
At first, nobody openly mentioned the B-words: breakthroughs and boosters. In the spring, the CDC encouraged, cajoled and, finally, pleaded with Americans to get the first COVID-19 vaccine available to them. Get your first shot. Don鈥檛 forget your second shot. (Michelle Deal-Zimmerman, 9/28)
As the U.S. and other developed countries start聽rolling聽 out Covid-19 vaccine booster shots, many are expressing concern that this will slow down the global vaccination campaign 鈥斅爌rolonging the pandemic and causing significant harm along the way. But there is a way to deliver boosters and speed up the next phase of vaccination at the same time. It鈥檚 the difference between pushing and pulling. (Scott Duke Kominers, 9/28)
The controversy over how the Biden administration decided who should get coronavirus booster shots underscores an important but seldom discussed point: Public health is not only about science; it鈥檚 also about societal values. 鈥淔ollow the science鈥 is a noble-sounding mantra that鈥檚 insufficient to account for the complexity of health policy decisions. (Leana S. Wen, 9/28)
At the end of August, police in China鈥檚 Hunan province came to the home of Zhang Jianping. They questioned him about why he had not been vaccinated against COVID-19, and took him by car to a hospital. In a social media post that included photos and videos to back up his story, Zhang said he was very clear that he did not want to be immunized. 鈥淚 am not informed. I do not consent,鈥 he says he told the authorities. But they held down his arms and legs and forcibly injected him. (Nicholas Goldberg, 9/29)
NBA games don鈥檛 begin until Oct. 19, but an unhealthy number of the league鈥檚 players are already refusing to get a Covid-19 vaccination. And their refusal could sabotage the 2021-22 season. Surprisingly, a small minority of anti-vax players has convinced the players' union that a vaccine mandate during a pandemic should be a 鈥渘on-starter鈥 for the league. The league cannot give in to this demand. It must instead insist that players be vaccinated, just as it has with referees and other people who will be near the players, such as security guards, bus drivers and massage therapists. (Cecil Harris, 9/28)